Fake reviews: how to report them and what to avoid
Photo: Avila Ops Tecnologia
Report a fake Google review through Business Profile itself, using the report-review option and selecting a reason such as conflict of interest or spam. First, reply publicly with one neutral line: “We found no service record under your name. If we served you, please contact us at this number.” Keep evidence that the person was not a customer. What to avoid: public accusations, buying positive reviews to compensate, or creating profiles to review yourself.
Fake reviews exist, and small businesses are easy targets: competitors, former employees, customers of another store with a similar name. But a wrong reaction costs more than the review. A profile replying with accusations, or suddenly gaining 20 five-star ratings the same day, draws Google’s and readers’ attention.
How can you tell whether a review is fake?
No sign alone proves it. Three together are usually enough:
- No record. You search the name in the CRM, system, calendar, and WhatsApp conversations, and find nobody. A business without customer records cannot even check this, a good reason to keep them.
- Generic content. “Terrible service, do not recommend,” without a date, product, or detail. Real customers usually explain what happened.
- Reviewer profile. An account created days ago, only one review, or multiple negative reviews the same day for businesses in the same industry and city.
- Timing. Several low ratings in succession right after a dispute with a competitor, dismissal, or public argument.
If the signs do not align, treat it as legitimate and use One star on Google: the response script. Erring toward a good reply costs less than erring toward accusation.
How do you report it, step by step?
- Reply publicly with one neutral line, without accusations. It remains visible while the report is reviewed.
- In Business Profile, open the review and use the report option. Select the applicable reason: spam, conflict of interest, off-topic.
- Register the request in Google’s reviews management tool, which shows review progress.
- Keep evidence: screenshot of the review, a no-results search in your system, reviewer profile.
- If the report is denied and you have solid evidence, appeal through the same tool.
Google gives no deadline and does not remove reviews simply because you ask; it removes policy violations. That is why step 1’s neutral line matters: it may be the only visible response for weeks.
When a fake review alleges a serious fact and names someone, such as accusing the owner of a crime, the legal route applies: a notice and, if necessary, an action for removal. That is for a lawyer, not a comment.
What should you avoid with fake reviews?
- Public accusations. “This is from a competitor” without evidence can be defamation, with you becoming the defendant.
- Buying reviews. This violates Google’s policy, may lead to legitimate reviews being removed too, and may constitute misleading advertising under the Consumer Protection Code (Law 8.078/1990).
- Asking friends and family to review. The same problem at a smaller scale.
- Responding with the supposed customer’s data. If there is no record, there is no data; if there is, exposing it creates an LGPD issue.
- Closing the profile. A closed profile disappears from the map, and the fake review will have cost your entire Google presence.
A salon received four one-star ratings in two days, all from new profiles with two-word text. The owner replied neutrally to each, reported all four with the same justification, and messaged the week’s customers asking them to review if they wanted, without tying it to anything. In 20 days, two fakes were removed, and eight new real-customer reviews pushed the other two down the list.
What to do now
Check today that your Business Profile has a verified owner and review notifications enabled. Without this, a fake review stays unanswered and unreported. Then build real review volume, the defense that works long term. Criteria for each complaint type are in Public complaints: reply, delete, or ignore. Google Business Profile configured with your website: avilaops.com/presenca-digital-para-pequenas-empresas or contact us on WhatsApp: wa.me/5517997811471.
Frequently asked questions
Does Google remove fake reviews?
When they violate its policy, such as spam, conflict of interest, or off-topic content. It does not remove them because the company disagrees. Reports must identify the violation, not the discomfort.
Can I sue someone who posted a fake review?
Yes, if it contains a false factual claim causing harm and the author can be identified. It is slow and expensive; for most cases, reporting and real review volume resolve it sooner.
Is an exaggerated review from a real customer fake?
No. Exaggeration from a real customer is criticism and should be answered as criticism. A fake review corresponds to no actual service.
Turn what you learned into your next step.
Tell us about your company and what you want to improve. We can explore the right tools, integrations or custom project together.